Cryptocurrency News

Bitcoin miners send less BTC to exchanges since 2020 halving despite FTX

Bitcoin (BTC) miners may be sending more BTC to exchanges this month — but overall, their sales have crashed since 2020.

Data from on-chain analytics platform CryptoQuant confirms that daily miner transfers to exchanges have decreased by two thirds or more.

Miners cool BTC exchange sales after FTX spike

After BTC/USD lost 25% in days last week, existing concerns over miner solvency have heightened.

Given their cost basis and rising hash rate, commentators warned that many mining participants may not be able to make ends meet — block subsidies and fees would not be enough to cancel out expenses, chiefly electricity.

Network fundamentals, however, tell a curious story — hash rate continues to circle all-time highs and not fall significantly, indicating that at least certain miners are maintaining network hashing power, not shutting down operations en masse.

3bf7a89d f9fd 4ec4 a8f7 c0aa055b26db
Bitcoin network fundamentals overview (screenshot). Source:

CryptoQuant meanwhile shows that on a daily basis, miners are not desperately selling coins to cover the shortfall in revenue.

On Nov. 8, the day of the FTX blowout, flows from miner wallets to exchanges totaled 1,300 BTC. This was the largest single-day tally since September.

Overall, the period of the FTX debacle has seen comparatively modest increase in selling compared to other spikes this year. Miners sent 4,540 BTC to exchanges on Sep. 2, while on June 22, around the time that BTC/USD dipped to then two-year lows of $17,600, the day’s total was 5,729 BTC.

9509c38d 21ea 470f ace9 72934d15a6b3
Bitcoin Miner to Exchange Flow (Total) chart. Source: CryptoQuant

Zooming out, the picture becomes even more nuanced.

Since Bitcoin’s last block subsidy halving event in May 2020, miners have significantly reduced their daily exchange sales.

Around the time of the halving, the seven-day moving average of miner exchange deposits was around 1,200 BTC per day.

The number varied significantly from day to day, but overall, what is considered a spike in November 2022 was standard practice at the time.

Fast forward to October this year, and on some days, miners sent under 100 BTC to exchanges.

The block subsidy may have halved and fees may account for less revenue in USD terms, but nevertheless, a clear trend is evident when it comes to exchange sales.

b80727d6 9b01 4f44 8837 3cbfa8ee2936
Bitcoin Miner to Exchange Flow (Total) chart. Source: CryptoQuant

Put another way, the FTX episode has produced only a brief divergence in miner outflows relative to their one-year moving average. This is summarized in CryptoQuant’s Miner Position Index (MPI).

50616223 15d9 43d3 87c2 0c6cabb12ac2
Bitcoin Miner Position Index (MPI) chart. Source: CryptoQuant

A taste of things to come?

As Cointelegraph reported, Bitcoin miners last experienced “distress” — in terms of on-chain data — in August.

Related: Elon Musk says BTC ‘will make it’ — 5 things to know in Bitcoin this week

The Hash Ribbons indicator, which is specifically designed to track miner capitulation, has been out of its red zone since then.

So far, nothing has managed to force a return to mass exiting by miners. This may yet change, as the latest Hash Ribbons chart data shows hash rate tendencies flattening out after several months of growth.

eb1906df 2764 4e66 a6df e5f9436acfec
Bitcoin Hash Ribbons chart. Source: LookIntoBitcoin

The views and opinions expressed here are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Every investment and trading move involves risk, you should conduct your own research when making a decision.